Regarding the refusal to consider Meruzhan Ghazaryan's application
To leave Meruzhan Ghazaryan's application of April 17, 2015, without consideration.
What was decided
- OtherOther
To leave Meruzhan Ghazaryan's application of April 17, 2015, h.15/20562 without consideration.
- Applicant: Meruzhan Ghazaryan
- OtherOther
This decision shall remain in force from the day following its receipt.
- OtherOther
This decision may be appealed administratively to the Mayor of Yerevan or to the Administrative Court of the Republic of Armenia within a two-month period from the date it enters into force.
Full text
DECISION OF THE MAYOR OF YEREVAN
1625-A, 29.05.2015
ON LEAVING MERUZHAN GHAZARYAN'S APPLICATION WITHOUT CONSIDERATION
1. Description of the issue resolved by the administrative act: By application No. 15/20562 dated April 17, 2015, addressed to the Mayor of Yerevan, Meruzhan Ghazaryan, on whose behalf Marine Yesayan acted in accordance with the power of attorney issued on March 12, 2015, requested to invalidate Decision No. 1995-A of the Mayor of Yerevan dated February 28, 2012 (hereinafter also referred to as the decision). On April 17, 2015, an administrative proceeding was initiated at Yerevan City Hall on the basis of subparagraph "a" of part 1 of Article 30 of the RA Law "On the Fundamentals of Administration and Administrative Procedure" for the purpose of considering the request made by Meruzhan Ghazaryan in application No. 15/20562 dated April 17, 2015. On May 5, 2015, hearings of the administrative proceeding were convened, which the participants of the proceeding did not attend. On May 22, 2015, the applicant Meruzhan Ghazaryan and his representative Marine Yesayan, representatives of the third party Hasmik Ghazaryan, Arman Apitonyan and Artashes Varosyan, who represented the latter's rights and interests on the basis of the power of attorney issued on March 12, 2015, attended the convened hearings.
2. Facts serving as grounds for adopting the administrative act:
1) Decision No. 1995-A of the Mayor of Yerevan dated February 28, 2012. 2) Oral statement of Arman Apitonyan, representative of Hasmik Ghazaryan, that Meruzhan Ghazaryan learned about the decision in November or December 2014, when by decision of the Court of General Jurisdiction of Kentron and Nork-Marash administrative districts of Yerevan city dated 03.11.2014, Hasmik Ghazaryan's claim against Meruzhan Ghazaryan and third party "Downtown Yerevan" CJSC regarding the demand for eviction was accepted for proceeding (civil case No. ԵԿԴ/4738/02/14). 3) Failure of the applicant Meruzhan Ghazaryan and his representative Marine Yesayan to submit an objection regarding the oral statement of Hasmik Ghazaryan's representative. 4) Absence of a motion to restore the missed deadline for appealing the decision.
3. Justifications for adopting the administrative act:
By application No. 15/20562 dated April 17, 2015, addressed to the Mayor of Yerevan, no motion was submitted by the applicant to restore the missed deadline for appealing the decision. During the administrative proceeding hearings, the issue of the absence of a motion to restore the missed deadline was discussed, but no motion was submitted by the applicant Meruzhan Ghazaryan and his representative Marine Yesayan to consider the missed deadline for appealing the decision as valid, or a motion to postpone the administrative proceeding hearings for the purpose of submitting such a motion.
According to Article 71 of the RA Law "On the Fundamentals of Administration and Administrative Procedure": "1. An administrative appeal may be filed: a) within 2 months from the day the administrative act enters into force.
…..
2. After missing the deadlines specified in part 1 of this Article, the act becomes unappealable. The appeal deadline may be restored if it was missed for a valid reason. A circumstance that may be considered a valid reason for missing the appeal deadline is missing the appeal deadline due to reasons beyond the control of the participant in the proceeding. After eliminating the reason(s) for missing the appeal deadline, the participant in the proceeding may submit an appeal within 15 days, indicating the reason(s) for missing the deadline. The administrative body in whose proceeding the administrative appeal is located restores the missed deadline and considers and resolves the appeal on its merits if it is substantiated by the appeal or during the consideration of the appeal that the appeal deadline was missed due to reasons beyond the control of the appellant (without his fault)."
According to parts 2 and 3 of Article 73 of the RA Law "On the Fundamentals of Administration and Administrative Procedure":
1) When accepting an appeal, the administrative body is obliged to check the compliance of the appeal with the requirements of Article 70 of the said law and to ascertain whether the appeal was filed within the deadline established by Article 71 of the said law. 2) When making a decision on the appeal, the appeal is left without consideration if it is submitted after the expiration of the deadline established by the said law, and the missing of the deadline has not been recognized as valid in the manner prescribed by part 2 of Article 71 of the said law.
Based on the foregoing and guided by Article 60 and part 3 of Article 73 of the Law of the Republic of Armenia "On the Fundamentals of Administration and Administrative Procedure":
I DECIDED
1. To leave Meruzhan Ghazaryan's application No. 15/20562 dated April 17, 2015, without consideration. 2. This decision enters into force on the day following its receipt. 3. This decision may be appealed administratively to the Mayor of Yerevan or to the Administrative Court of the Republic of Armenia within a two-month period from the day it enters into force.
MAYOR OF YEREVAN T. MARGARYAN