Skip to main content
Turn on red

Alexander Tatevyan's comments on the traffic-light draft and the ministry's replies

Alexander Tatevyan

"the presence of flashing informational light sections, lunar white in color, with the outline of a person and an arrow, which warn drivers that pedestrians are on the crossing."

The draft does not specify which crossing the section refers to: the one before the intersection or the one after it (after the turn). Judging by the pictogram on the section, it is the one after the turn. That is how it works in Moscow, for example, where this section was designed and put into use. But in the context of the local non-standard traffic layout it causes confusion, because it presumably warns of pedestrians on the crossing located before the intersection, contrary to what the pictogram means. So either change the pictogram or remove the conflict mode with the pedestrian crossing before the intersection, leaving the flows to cross only on leaving the intersection (after the turn).

The ministry's reply

The traffic lights in question (before the intersection or after it) are installed before the intersection, to inform drivers turning right or left that a pedestrian is likely to be present. The right and left arrows already make clear that the light refers to the crossings on the right or left side after the intersection, so there is no need to specify which crossing it refers to. Your point about confusing situations is well taken: there are intersections in Yerevan where the locations of the traffic lights installed by Yerevan Municipality need to be reviewed (for example, at the intersection of Leningradyan, Sebastia and Hasratyan streets the arrow of the light installed in the direction of Leningradyan Street points right, but in fact vehicles and pedestrians cross paths before the turn is made). Given that Yerevan Municipality's installation of these lights at intersections is experimental, and that the provisions on where they are placed have only just been drafted and are still under discussion, there may be some inconsistencies, which will be corrected once the above drafts are approved.

Alexander Tatevyan

"51. The informational light signal comes on together with the permissive signal of the traffic light during which turning vehicles may cross paths with pedestrians."

This gives the drivers of vehicles approaching the intersection, or already close to it, no chance to learn in advance that pedestrians have appeared on the crossing. It is enough to watch the recordings from intersection cameras to see that this signal should come on and go off with a time offset from the pedestrians' permissive signal: at least a few seconds before it and a few seconds after.

The ministry's reply

We offer the following clarification.

The lights are placed under the main vehicle traffic light whose permissive signal comes on together with the permissive signals of the pedestrian lights on the right or left side after the intersection. Only under these conditions does the flashing signal of the informational light section come on, together with the signal of the main light. Switching these lights on with a time offset would confuse drivers. A driver who enters the intersection in compliance with the traffic lights will see the informational light signal in time.

Alexander Tatevyan

"It is permitted to place under a vehicle traffic light flashing informational light sections, lunar white in color, with the outline of a person and an arrow, which warn drivers that pedestrians are on the crossing."

And what does it require under the Road Traffic Rules? Let me just remind you that to this day the Rules contain no clear requirement to give way to pedestrians before entering a regulated intersection.

The ministry's reply

As for the Road Traffic Rules: the flashing informational light sections, lunar white in color, with the outline of a person and an arrow, are technical means of additional information that raise the driver's alertness and attention. A driver turning right or left at an intersection may often, for one reason or another (limited or insufficient visibility, a large turning radius and so on), fail to notice that the pedestrian light is also on in the direction of the turn. In that case the flashing signal of the informational light section tells the driver in advance that the permissive signal of the pedestrian light is also on in the direction of the turn; consequently, on approaching the pedestrian crossing the driver must comply with point 87 of Chapter 10 of Annex N 1 to Government Decision N 955-N of 28 June 2007.

Under point 87 of Chapter 10 of Annex N 1 to Government Decision N 955-N of 28 June 2007, when turning right or left, on leaving the intersection the driver must not impede pedestrians crossing the carriageway and must give way to cyclists riding on a cycle track. And although point 87 does not name the type of intersection, it applies to regulated intersections as well, given that the Road Traffic Rules of the Republic of Armenia fully comply with the requirements of the 1968 Vienna Convention on Road Traffic. In particular, under Article 21(2)(a), if vehicular traffic is regulated at that crossing by traffic light signals or by an authorized official, drivers forbidden to proceed shall stop short of the crossing or the transverse markings preceding it and, when they are permitted to proceed, shall not prevent or obstruct the passage of pedestrians who have stepped on to it; drivers turning into another road at the entrance to which there is a pedestrian crossing shall do so slowly and give way, if necessary stopping for this purpose, to pedestrians already using, or about to use, the crossing. The remark that there is no clear requirement to give way to pedestrians before entering a regulated intersection is therefore unfounded.

Alexander Tatevyan

Having read your clarifications, I find it necessary to stress again that this is about crossing paths with crossings located before the intersection. Your arguments, fair for the most part, concern only crossing paths with crossings located after the intersection, on the right or left. So neither point 87 nor the Convention's provision covers the so-called experimental traffic-light configuration (a permanently open right turn) introduced jointly by the municipality and the Road Police. In particular, the Convention requirement you cite about giving way to pedestrians before the intersection, which incidentally coincides with point 105 of the Road Traffic Rules, does not deal with pedestrians preparing to cross; it concerns only those finishing the crossing, and only once a permissive signal has followed a prohibiting one. It therefore makes no sense to tie this requirement to a permissive signal that is lit all the time. So either the problematic and extremely dangerous experiment, which has gone on for years, must be stopped at once, or the draft decision must be changed to take account of the important comments I have submitted. In addition, maximum time limits and safety conditions need to be set for experimental changes of any kind to road traffic, because the experimental change under discussion in effect remains, without interruption, a source of extreme danger to people's lives and health, and at the same time flatly contradicts Article 1(2) of the Law "On Ensuring Road Traffic Safety" of the Republic of Armenia, which requires that the lives, health and property of citizens, their rights and lawful interests, and the interests of society and the state be protected by preventing threats to road traffic safety, road accidents in particular, and by reducing their severity and consequences.

The ministry's reply

By way of clarification: Article 21(2)(a) of the 1968 Vienna Convention on Road Traffic, which we quoted (hereinafter, the Convention requirement), concerned the requirement to give way to pedestrians using a regulated pedestrian crossing located after a right or left turn at the intersection, while the pedestrians' permissive signal is on (we quote the part of the Convention that corresponds to point 87: drivers turning into another road at the entrance to which there is a pedestrian crossing shall do so slowly and give way, if necessary stopping for this purpose, to pedestrians already using, or about to use, the crossing).

As for crossing paths with crossings located before the intersection (when the additional right-hand section of the traffic light is permanently lit and the paths cross before the vehicle turns), we share your concern and inform you that such intersections are already at the center of attention of the Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructure. We also assure you that once the draft law is approved, both the locations of the flashing informational light sections, lunar white in color, with the outline of a person and an arrow, and the advisability of pedestrians and vehicles moving at the same time will be reviewed jointly with Yerevan Municipality and the Road Police.

We would also like to thank you for the observations you raised and for your proposals on improving road traffic safety.